| Pacesetter ($10,000 - $24,999) |
| July 1, 2011 - June 30, 2012 |
| |
| Individuals |
| Anonymous | Jon & Cindy Elsasser Zoar |
| Bob & Liz Fox Lancaster | Tad & Nancy Jeffrey Columbus |
| E. Sandra Paul Columbus | Estate of Katherine Rowland Lebanon |
| James H. & Barbara Rutherford New Albany | Ronald J. Ungvarsky & Susan Tomasky Bexley |
| | |
| Businesses, Foundations and Organizations | |
| Anonymous | Army of the Ohio Grove City |
| Conestoga Columbus | Dayton Foundation Dayton |
| Edgar W. Ingram-White Castle Foundation Columbus | G. Whitney Snyder Charitable Fund Princeton, NJ |
| Gordon Chandler Memorial Fund of The Columbus Foundation Columbus | Honda of America Mfg., Inc. Marysville |
| Mabel and Vernon Watts Educational Fund of The Columbus Foundation Columbus | Nancy Wolfe Lane Family Fund of The Columbus Foundation Columbus |